STATEN ISLAND, N.Y. -- Every Staten Island public high school has a dress code -- based on Department of Education regulations -- but the emphasis each school places on enforcement of the code, and how it disciplines students in violation is a reflection of the school's priorities, and the management style of the principal and administration. The uproar at...
STATEN ISLAND, N.Y. -- Every Staten Island public high school has a dress code -- based on Department of Education regulations -- but the emphasis each school places on enforcement of the code, and how it disciplines students in violation is a reflection of the school's priorities, and the management style of the principal and administration.
The uproar at Tottenville High School, that came with the crackdown of the dress code the first week of school is an example.
The school rounded up more than 200 students -- most of them girls-- at the door and in the hallways -- for being scantily dressed -- and detained them from class until they could cover up -- which in some cases involved summoning parents.
Acting Tottenville Principal Joseph Scaramuto unleashed a range of reaction for his handling, ranging from those calling it "arbitrary" and "sexist" to those who thought it taught the right lesson for the South Shore's student body.
There are items in the dress code that are the same at every school, such as a ban on wearing hoods, hats, bandanas, do-rags and sunglasses in the building; shirts with offensive or violent messages, and belts and accessories with chains or spikes, as well as all electronic devices, including cellphones and headphones. These items were banned by the Department of Education under the Bloomberg administration, in an attempt to discourage gang activity in the high schools.
Beyond those items, "Students have the right to determine their own dress except where such dress creates a distraction, is dangerous or interferes with the learning and teaching process," according to High Schools Superintendent Aimee Horowitz.
The principal has the discretion of determining what creates a "distraction, is dangerous or interferes with the learning and teaching process."
The Advance visited each of the borough's public high schools, and found each school had its own style of handling student dress. We talked to students, as well as administrators, although most administrators refused to comment.
Students were more frank.
CURTIS HIGH SCHOOL
At Curtis High School, the emphasis is on hats, hoods, cellphones, headphones and electronic devices, students said.
Curtis High School junior, Jonathan Navarro says, at Curtis 'the deans watch us as we walk through the hallways.' (Staten Island Advance/Jan Somma-Hammel)
"They really enforce it. The deans watch us when we walk in and in the hallways. If they see you with a hat or hood on, a phone or earphones, they tell you to put it away, or they'll confiscate it," said Curtis junior Jonathan Navarro.
"Occasionally, a girl gets called into the dean's office if she's wearing something too revealing, and they give her a T-shirt to put on. They also tell guys to pull up their pants," he said. "But no detentions."
Junior Celeste Leno said she's glad that Curtis administrators are on top of the siituation, without "embarrassing" students. "They get the message out that we have to respect ourselves," she said.
McKEE HIGH SCHOOL
McKee High School athletes DeAndre Greene and Mark Perez say McKee is strict about boys wearing hats and hoods in the building. (Staten Island Advance/Jan Somma-Hammel)
The situation is similar at neighboring McKee High School.
McKee freshman Esmerelda Ramon said all the rules are spelled out in the school handbook each student receives. "We can wear shorts, but not short-shorts," she explained.
Juniors DeAndre Greene and Mark Perez said McKee is strict about boys wearing hats and hoods in the building. "They call us out for that, but some of them still do it. They're a bit hard-headed, I guess," Perez said. He said deans will confiscate hats and tell students to remove hooded sweatshirts and change shirts if they are defiant.
CONCORD HIGH SCHOOL
Principal Ronald J. Gorsky of Concord High School said he instituted 'Spirit Fridays.' (Staten Island Advance/Jan Somma-Hammel)
Over at Concord High School, Principal Ron Gorsky, who was standing on the sidewalk observing students enter and leave the building, said he instituted "Spirit Fridays" where both students and faculty are encouraged to wear clothing displaying the school colors of black and silver.
"Any student who comes in improperly dressed, we provide them with a school T-shirt, and we talk to them about how important it is that they be prepared to learn," Gorsky said. "Once they realize what's expected of them, they comply."
"We shouldn't have to say 'cover up' to another girl. She should respect herself enough to know better," said Concord junior Cheyenne Mieles. "Maybe we need a class to teach self-respect, and how to dress right," she suggested.
Joshua Monroy, a sophomore at Port Richmond High School, is not bothered by the dress code. (Staten Island Advance/Jan Somma-Hammel)
PORT RICHMOND HIGH SCHOOL
Port Richmond High School students said they didn't think the dress code was an issue in the school.
"We should be allowed to dress the way we want, within reason," opined Port Richmond sophomore Joshua Monroy.
Senior Venus Collins said she's seen a few of her classmates stopped for being scantily clad. "They give you a shirt or gym suit, to cover up," she said.
"I think that's the right thing to do. At home you can dress the way you want, but you should be dressed properly for school," she said.
SUSAN WAGNER HIGH SCHOOL
Sarah Cstellano is a freshman at Wagner High School. She agrees with her mother Evelyn Ocasio that the school is not a beach, and students should cover up. (Staten Island Advance/Jan Somma-Hammel)
Susan Wagner High School students said Principal Gary Giordano and his staff "are pretty strict" about student dress.
"You're not allowed to wear tank tops or athletic jerseys, and you have to take off your hat and sunglasses. If you don't follow the rules, you get stopped, and if you still don't, you get suspended," said Susan Wagner sophomore Michael Calzaretta.
"They're just doing their job," said junior Christian Hernandez.
Mom Evelyn Ocasio said she's happy Susan Wagner is "strict about what students wear to class." "Girls have to be taught how to behave and have respect for themselves," she said.
Her daughter, freshman Sarah Castellano, agreed. "I've seen girls walking around in halter tops and short-shorts. They need to learn that school is not the beach."
NEW DORP HIGH SCHOOL
New Dorp High School sophomore Christian Chesner said school officials try not to embarrass students who violate the dress code. (Staten Island Advance/Jan Somma-Hammel)
At both New Dorp High School and Staten Island Technical High School, New Dorp, students said the administration is a bit more laid-back about the dress code, but students get the message nonetheless.
"We know we're not supposed to dress in a certain way, and if there's a girl or guy who is dressed inappropriately, they call you aside quietly, and tell you so," said New Dorp sophomore Christian Chesner. "They are more concerned about fighting; if you're caught fighting, you get suspended," he added.
"They treat us like young adults; they don't embarrass us," said senior Rafael Zelayandia. "Most people are smart enough to know how to dress for school."
Tell us what you think of your school's dress code and how it's enforced in the comments field below.